Up for your consideration is this replacement game part. It came out of a 1986 game version. I am not sure if it is compatible with other versions or not. If you need more (or less) than 5 pieces just let me know (no additional cost) as I have a lot of them. Each piece roughly measures 1" x .75".

Please see pictures for details and reach out with any questions you may have. Smoke free home. I am happy to combine postage for multiple items purchased from my store.