These Fendi Heels were bought new in 2019. There are some scuffs throughout, though worn under 5 times. The white patent leather has a dig on one heel and a tiny puncture on the other heel. They are not for a super wide foot. The red leather, metallics, calfhair, and textured white heel make these super dynamic. I'm sure they could be cleaned even better with real shoe products. They are comfortable enough to manage, but would be more comfortable for a petite person. COMES WITH FENDI SHOE BOX