John Sayre worked in different New York locations and even New Jersey. This is a fine old tablespoon with good length and weight (9.25 inches, 56 grams). The drop on the bowl back is typical of higher quality spoons.
A date was added on the back, probably by an enthusiastic collector. Would you have done this? Me neither. Condition is very good but with some tip wear.
Pricing represents our new economic reality. Hang onto your hats.