LEO MATTEL History (1986 - 2000)
Mattel
entered the Indian market in 1986-1987 in hopes of conquering the
Indian toy market. The Indian foreign trade laws, however, did not favor
the presence of a multinational company like Mattel. India’s foreign
trade policy severely limited importation and foreign direct
investments, making it immensely difficult for multinationals to conduct
business in India until 1991. The foreign companies or investors in
India were unwelcome as a result of a long-standing national policy of
economic self-reliance, a legacy of India’s independence from the
British crown in 1947.
Foreign
direct investment was limited under the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act
(FERA). FERA mandated that all companies holding more than 40 percent
equity in an Indian subsidiary register themselves under FERA. Companies
registered under FERA ultimately were forced to dilute their shares to
40 percent in order to transform the business into an Indian company.
Companies that failed to register under FERA or refused to dilute their
shares were forced to shut down business in India.
In
order to avoid classification as a FERA company, Mattel chose to enter
into a joint venture with an Indian marketing company Blow Plast, Inc.
and created an Indian affiliate, known as Leo Mattel, or Leo Toys.
Because of the 41 percent ceiling on foreign direct investment (FDI),
Blow Plast held 60 percent and Mattel held the other 40 percent. Scince
Mattel stayed below the FDI ceiling by creating Leo Mattel, it was then
not subject to classification as a FERA company.
Leo
Mattel was afforded the same national treatment as an Indian company.
National treatment, however, did not mean the luxury of freely importing
raw materials from China or elsewhere. Foreign direct investments and
the corporate law of India did not cause Mattel problems just yet. The
QRs, however, were still in place and prevented Mattel from using its
preexisting production facilities in neighboring Asian countries, like
China and Japan. Hands tied by the restrictive import laws, Leo Mattel
set up a factory in Mumbai and a production facility nearby in Nagpur.
Mattel
maintained the Leo Mattel joint venture for the majority of the 1990s.
In July 1991, thanks to the lift in import restrictions, Mattel was
finally able to import the principal materials it needed. However it was
not until Mattel ended its joint venture with Blow Plast, and thus
ended the era of Leo Mattel, that Mattel took advantage of the new
ceiling on foreign direct investment.
By 2000, Mattel terminated the joint venture on the grounds that Blow Plast failed to meet Mattel’s quality standards.
L Wall: 182