You are buying two artichoke plates by Gien of France as seen in the pictures. Both plates have crazing on the back with one plate having a little on the front. One plate has a dark spot under the glaze on the front as seen in one picture. Both have small scapes of the glaze on the bottom rim and one plate has a scrape on the top side rim where the glaze is scraped off. See the pictures for the scrapes. These plates would go good with an existing set.