They come from a family in the Champagne France area. They have been well used and show signs of wear but are still shiny and beautiful. They have lots is scratches on the back. Some have a scratch across the handle and dull spots. Please see pictures for more details.We are also listing separately dessert forks, dinner forks, dessert knives, dinner knives, dinner and dessert spoons. Please let us know if you have any questions. Thank you for viewing this listing.