How I rate my items:

EXCELLENT: Used with almost no signs of use.

Very Good  : Used, showing minor signs of use.

Good : Used, showing age appropriate signs of use such as minor scratches & minor wear, no cracks or missing pieces. 

Other : Occasionally I will sell an item with significant wear, including dents, scratches, corrosion, etc. This occurs when I find an item that is very rare or still significantly interesting to sell in this condition.