I just took these off my commuter/trainer bike. The left shifter still ratchets and shifts very well. The right shifter is beginning to miss shifts under load while riding but will still shift beautifully with the bike in a repair stand - so it's definitely time for a rebuild. They are in overall good cosmetic shape, some scratches on the levers and a few on the front of the shifter bodies from normal use over the seasons. I replaced the hoods last year, hoods are still in very nice condition. I have 'upgraded' to 9 speed so the 8 speed gear is going.