1.  Ty Clubby Beanie (1998 tush tag) and Buddy (1999 tush tag) are royal blue with a rainbow colored ribbon around the neck, Ty Beanie Babies Official Club logo button on the front, and mint hang tags.

2.  Ty Clubby II Beanie and Buddy are blue with a silver ribbon around the neck, 1999 tush tags and mint hang tags.  Please see the photo to see one of these Beanie Babies has a "Clubby" tush tag which was an error.  I have included both versions.

3.  Ty Clubby III Beanie and Buddy are golden-blue tie dye with royal blue ribbons around the neck, Ty Beanie Babies Official Club logo button on the front, 2000 tush tags and mint hang tags.

4.  Ty Clubby IV Beanie Baby and Buddy are purple-hues tie dye with a purple ribbon around the neck, Ty Beanie Babies Official Club logo button on the front, 2001 tush tags and mint hang tags.

5.  Ty Clubby V Beanie Baby and Buddy are hot pink tie dye with a rainbow colored ribbon around the neck, 2002 tush tags and mint hang tags.

6.  Ty Clubby VI Beanie Babies (2003 tush tags) and Buddy (2004 tush tag) are rainbow colored tie dye with rainbow colored ribbon around the neck, Ty Beanie Babies Official Club logo button on the front and mint hang tags.  There were 3 Clubby VI beanie babies total including a blue tie dye and a purple tie dye sitting version bears with matching ribbons.  Please see photo.

7.  Ty Clubby VII Beanie Baby is pastel rainbow colored, with a rainbow ribbon around the neck, Ty Beanie Babies Official Club logo button on the front, 2006 tush tag and mint hang tag.

8.  Ty Clubby VIII is purple and white tie dye with a silver ribbon around the neck, Ty Beanie Babies Official Club logo button on the front, 2007 tush tag and mint hang tag.

9.  The Ty Jingle Beanies Collection Clubby Edition includes Clubby I-IV in the original box which has been opened.  The beanies all match the Clubby I-IV beanies and buddies described above, with 2001 tush tags and mint hang tags.

All come with tag protectors.