«This is the most comprehensive English-language study to date of Chinese narratives about female knights-errant or swordswomen ('nüxia'). (...) Altenburger's research is thorough, and his examinations of texts are careful, cogently argued, and meticulously documented. Summing Up: Highly recommended.» (Y. Wu, Choice)
«'The Sword or the Needle' est un ouvrage passionnant, riche et novateur, qui jette sur les femmes de la Chine traditionnelle un regard décalé mais particulièrement instructif.» (Nicolas Zufferey, Études chinoises)
«This is a fine book with a wealth of detail about 'nüxia' narratives in Chinese culture from Tang times to the 1930s. [...] Altenburger's insistence on the ambiguity, complexity, and importance of the female knight-errant tradition is well taken. He has written a comprehensive and erudite study that deserves a wide reading.» (Paul S. Ropp, China Review International 18, 2011/1)