Both dies and planchet show signs of special preparation, so could be a WWII Branch Mint Proof. Reflective PROOFLIKE fields. 

Legendary expert Walter Breen believed that Branch Mint Proof silver war nickels were minted. This could be one of them. 

NGC STAR population just 67 in ALL grades combined versus 6,008 non-STAR. 

Member of prestigious CDN Exchange (aka Greysheet aka Coinplex) since 2011 and its third highest bidder in dollar volume. Fewer than 300 members worldwide. Click our username to see our other credentials at the top of our homepage. 

▶NOTE: Five day return privilege.