As these have been discontinued, some may be past the expiration date. Please note: Many of our cosmetic items are retail shelf pulls (meaning product that has been taken off of store shelfs to make room for changing/new inventory).  Because of this you may find some light packaging damage such as scratches, sticker residue, dents or taped packages. It is important to know this light wear affects only the packaging, not the product itself. The product itself is brand new & often in still sealed packaging. Some of the applicator sponges have faded/discolored from time &/or light exposure.