THIS coin is au.And has some mint luster.Holder says there is a scuff.As I could knot see one when I blew up pictures. Also there is a brown spot.Above he's eye brow.On Philip The first face.There are no marks on coin or holder no scratches on coin or surfaces or holder.There is a break in flat on reverse woman with torch.Coin has some mint luster.No flann cracks or flann flaws.Silver is very verry nice.Surfaces are bright and free of spots or heavy toneing. You decide.