| | | 1 | | Nolan Ryan National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Texas Rangers |
| | | 2 | | Rickey Henderson RB National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Oakland Athletics |
| | | 4 | | Nolan Ryan RB National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Texas Rangers |
| | | 5 | | Dave Winfield RB National Baseball Hall of Fame | | California Angels |
| | | 10 | | Wade Boggs National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 40 | | Cal Ripken National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles |
| | | 45 | | Gary Carter National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| | | 50 | | Ken Griffey Jr. National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Seattle Mariners |
| | | 78 | | Ivan Rodriguez ASR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Texas Rangers |
| | | 90 | | Robin Yount National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Milwaukee Brewers |
| | | 110 | | Ryne Sandberg National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago Cubs |
| | | 120 | | Alan Trammell National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Detroit Tigers |
| | | 215 | | Rich Gossage National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Texas Rangers |
| | | 225 | | Roberto Alomar National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Toronto Blue Jays |
| | | 235 | | Jack Morris National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Minnesota Twins |
| | | 242 | | Mike Mussina National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles |
| | | 245 | | John Smoltz National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Atlanta Braves |
| | | 261 | | Tom Lasorda MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| | | 270 | | Tony Gwynn National Baseball Hall of Fame | | San Diego Padres |
| | | 305 | | Tom Glavine National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Atlanta Braves |
| | | 375 | | Bert Blyleven National Baseball Hall of Fame | | California Angels |
| | | 381 | | Sparky Anderson MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Detroit Tigers |
| | | 387 | | Ryne Sandberg AS, LL National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago Cubs |
| | | 389 | | Barry Larkin AS, LL National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Cincinnati Reds |
| | | 393 | | Craig Biggio AS, LL National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Houston Astros |
| | | 395 | | Tom Glavine AS, LL National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Atlanta Braves |
| | | 396 | | Lee Smith AS, LL National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 399 | | Wade Boggs AS, LL National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 400 | | Cal Ripken AS, LL National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles |
| | | 426 | | Rock Raines National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago White Sox |
| | | 429 | | Tony La Russa MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Oakland Athletics |
| | | 460 | | Andre Dawson National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago Cubs |
| | | 465 | | Barry Larkin National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Cincinnati Reds |
| | | 489 | | Bobby Cox MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Atlanta Braves |
| | | 520 | | Jeff Bagwell ASR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Houston Astros |
| | | 525 | | Randy Johnson National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Seattle Mariners |
| | | 531 | | Larry Walker National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Montreal Expos |
| | | 549 | | Joe Torre MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 551 | | 1992 Top Prospects Shortstops (Manny Alexander / Alex Arias / Wil Cordero / Chipper Jones) TP, RC National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles / Chicago Cubs / Montreal Expos / Atlanta Braves |
| | | 553 | | Edgar Martinez National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Seattle Mariners |
| | | 555 | | Frank Thomas National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago White Sox |
| | | 560 | | Rickey Henderson National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Oakland Athletics |
| | | 565 | | Lee Smith National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 575 | | Kirby Puckett National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Minnesota Twins |
| | | 580 | | Greg Maddux National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago Cubs |
| | | 600 | | Paul Molitor National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Milwaukee Brewers |
| | | 620 | | George Brett National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Kansas City Royals |
| | | 630 | | Carlton Fisk National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago White Sox |
| | | 635 | | Harold Baines National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Oakland Athletics |
| | | 715 | | Craig Biggio National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Houston Astros |
| | | 738 | | Dennis Eckersley National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Oakland Athletics |
| | | 760 | | Ozzie Smith National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 768 | | Jim Thome National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Cleveland Indians |
| | | 780 | | Eddie Murray National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| | | 792 | | Dave Winfield National Baseball Hall of Fame | | California Angels |