'Black Girl' Ossie Davis Directs Miss Franklin's Play A High
School Dropout Seeks to Be Dancer
Published: November 10, 1972
Mama Rosie works as a school janitor to support her
daughters, teenager Billie Jean and older half-sisters Norma and Ruth Ann. The
family lives in a disheveled rental house, which they share with Mama Rosie's
mother, Mu' Dear and Mu' Dear's boyfriend Herbert. Although both the pregnant
Ruth Ann and Norma have several children, neither is married or plans to leave
the house. Billie Jean, who believes that a career as a professional dancer
will lead her out of poverty and prevent her from suffering her sisters' fate,
practices daily despite their resentment and constant taunting. When Mama Rosie
one day learns that Billie Jean has quit high school to be a waitress and dance
at the Groovy Bar and Grill, she laments that Netta, one of several
neighborhood girls Mama Rosie has fostered over the years, is the only child to
go to college. After ridiculing her real daughters for failing to live up to
Netta's example, Mama Rosie calls Netta at her university to ask her to come
home for Mother's Day, and fantasizes that Netta will soon teach at the school
where she works, providing her with some recognition and a sense of
accomplishment. One day, Norma and Ruth Ann's long-absent father Earl shows up
unexpectedly from Detroit, where he works as a shoe salesman. Easily impressing
Ruth Ann and Norma with his new El Dorado Cadillac car and cash handouts, Earl
hopes to win back Mama Rosie's affection. When a skeptical Mu' Dear admonishes
him for refusing to give money to Billie Jean, who was born out of wedlock and
fathered by another man, Earl reasons that she is not his child and insinuates
that Billie Jean's dancing aspirations will only lead to working as a stripper.
Instead of defending Billie Jean, Mama Rosie brags about Netta and the other
girls she has fostered, claiming that her real children do not appreciate her
as the others do. In a moment alone with Mama Rosie, Earl asks her if she would
consider a reconciliation. When she refuses, Earl offers her one thousand
dollars and tells her to call him when she finds what she is looking for in a
man, but Mama Rosie is reluctant to accept his empty promises of devotion and
is not shocked when Earl takes back the money. After Earl departs, Mama Rosie
vehemently ridicules her mother for living with Herbert "in sin," but
wise Mu' Dear advises Mama Rosie to let go of her old resentments before they
destroy the family. As Mama Rosie anxiously awaits Netta's letter regarding a
Mother's Day visit, Norma and Ruth Ann conspire to turn Billie Jean against
their mother and Netta, whom they fear will encourage Billie Jean's blossoming
independence. Alone with Billie Jean, the two tell her that Mama Rosie secretly
wishes Billie Jean would marry and leave the house, adding that Mama Rosie will
give Billie Jean's room to Netta when she returns to teach at Mama Rosie's
school. Fearing that the foster daughter will claim what little affection her
mother has for her, Billie Jean agrees to hide any letters from Netta. On
Mother's Day, Mama Rosie, unaware that Netta has written to arrange a visit, is
at work when her foster daughter arrives at the house. Ruth Ann and Norma mock
the properly dressed college student. Surmising that Norma and Ruth Ann have
hardened against her since her departure, Netta tries to reestablish her
relationship with Billie Jean and asks if she has considered applying to the
dance competition about which she had written to Billie Jean. The teenager then
realizes that her half-sisters have been keeping Netta's letters from her and
eagerly considers Netta's offer to live with her while Billie Jean finishes
high school and goes to college. Wanting to discourage Billie Jean's dreams,
Norma and Ruth Ann retort that Netta's sole motivation for attending college is
to sleep with white boys. When Netta announces that she is a virgin, the sisters
mercilessly badger her for being a prude. Insulted, Netta leaves the house but,
before going, tells Billie Jean that her dancing is very special. That Sunday,
Mama Rosie and her daughters attend church, where Netta has taken her
biological mother, a woman wheel-chair bound and catatonic from mental illness.
Spotting Netta in the back of the church, Mama Rosie rushes to her foster
daughter with great pride, but Netta explains that her first duty is to her
real mother now. Later, back at home, when Mama Rosie questions Billie Jean
about her future, Billie Jean discloses Netta's proposal for her to finish
school. Willing to do anything to thwart Billie Jean's ambitions, Ruth Ann and
Norma insist that a truancy officer should be called to handle their half-sister's
misbehavior and wrestle her to the ground, forcing Herbert to call for Mu' Dear
to resolve the situation. The matriarch admonishes her daughter about caring
for strangers' children more than her own and tells her to let Billie Jean live
her life, saying "She can't do no worse with hers, than what you done with
yours." Days later, Billie Jean has packed her bags and leaves for school
after embracing Mama Rosie, who tells Mu' Dear that she had never meant to hurt
Billie Jean, only to ensure she and the other girls did not end up "just
like me."