| | | 1 | | Ozzie Smith National Baseball Hall of Fame | | San Diego Padres |
| | | 2 | | Rollie Fingers National Baseball Hall of Fame | | San Diego Padres |
| | | 5 | | Alan Trammell National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Detroit Tigers |
| | | 11 | | Mike Schmidt National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Philadelphia Phillies |
| | | 12 | | Willie Stargell National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| | | 18 | | Joe Morgan National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Houston Astros |
| | | 33 | | Steve Carlton National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Philadelphia Phillies |
| | | 49 | | Rod Carew National Baseball Hall of Fame | | California Angels |
| | | 58 | | Don Sutton National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| | | 62 | | Johnny Bench National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Cincinnati Reds |
| | | 90 | | Gary Carter National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Montreal Expos |
| | | 94 | | Carl Yastrzemski National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 96 | | Dennis Eckersley National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 100 | | George Brett National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Kansas City Royals |
| | | 112 | | Eddie Murray National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles |
| | | 119 | | Rickey Henderson National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Oakland Athletics |
| | | 127 | | Jack Morris National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Detroit Tigers |
| | | 132 | | Willie Stargell National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| | | 135 | | Bert Blyleven National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| | | 146 | | Ferguson Jenkins National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Texas Rangers |
| | | 169 | | Rod Carew National Baseball Hall of Fame | | California Angels |
| | | 182 | | Johnny Bench National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Cincinnati Reds |
| | | 203 | | Paul Molitor National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Milwaukee Brewers |
| | | 212 | | Andre Dawson UER National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Montreal Expos |
| | | 214 | | Carl Yastrzemski National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 228 | | Reggie Jackson National Baseball Hall of Fame | | New York Yankees |
| | | 260 | | Nolan Ryan National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Houston Astros |
| | | 308 | | Ted Simmons National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 323 | | Robin Yount National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Milwaukee Brewers |
| | | 328 | | Phil Niekro National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Atlanta Braves |
| | | 334 | | Tony Perez National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 335 | | Carlton Fisk National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 338 | | Jim Rice National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Boston Red Sox |
| | | 347 | | Rich Gossage National Baseball Hall of Fame | | New York Yankees |
| | | 348 | | Reggie Jackson National Baseball Hall of Fame | | New York Yankees |
| | | 351 | | Yogi Berra CO National Baseball Hall of Fame | | New York Yankees |
| | | 353 | | Jim Palmer National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles |
| | | 356 | | Earl Weaver MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles |
| | | 364 | | Dave Winfield National Baseball Hall of Fame | | San Diego Padres |
| | | 370 | | Sparky Anderson MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Detroit Tigers |
| | | 402 | | Tony LaRussa MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Chicago White Sox |
| | | 420 | | Tommy Lasorda MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| | | 422 | | Tom Seaver National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Cincinnati Reds |
| | | 425 | | Tom Seaver National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Cincinnati Reds |
| | | 426 | | Bobby Cox MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Atlanta Braves |
| | | 431 | | Red Schoendienst MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 453 | | Dick Williams MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Montreal Expos |
| | | 468 | | Reggie Jackson UER National Baseball Hall of Fame | | New York Yankees |
| | | 471 | | Gaylord Perry National Baseball Hall of Fame | | New York Yankees |
| | | 473 | | Jim Palmer National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Baltimore Orioles |
| | | 481 | | Steve Carlton AW National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Philadelphia Phillies |
| | | 491 | | George Brett MVP National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Kansas City Royals |
| | | 506 | | Joe Torre MGR National Baseball Hall of Fame | | New York Mets |
| | | 536 | | Jim Kaat National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 537 | | Best Hitters (George Brett / Rod Carew) National Baseball Hall of Fame, National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Kansas City Royals / California Angels |
| | | 538 | | Tim Raines RC National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Montreal Expos |
| | | 560 | | Bruce Sutter National Baseball Hall of Fame | | St. Louis Cardinals |
| | | 590 | | Mike Schmidt MVP National Baseball Hall of Fame | | Philadelphia Phillies |