Pick your own 8 Tastykake Baked Pies! Mix and match to choose any combination of 8 pies from year round flavors (French Apple, Apple, Cherry, Lemon, and Blueberry) and seasonal flavors (currently Peach, S’mores, Banana Split, Orange Créme, Blueberry Cheesecake, and Lemon Cheesecake). Seasonal flavors change often throughout the year, please see the picture on the listing for current seasonal flavors.

After placing an order, please use “Contact Buyer” to let us know how many of what pies you would like. If we don’t hear from you within 24 hours, we will ship an assortment of our choosing.

Tastykake baked pies are baked fresh and use fresh fruit ingredients which lead to a very short shelf life. We guarantee that your product will be the freshest possible upon shipment and delivery but cannot guarantee a specific number of days before expiration upon their delivery.